Research question & contribution
Is the question explicit? Does the introduction explain the gap and the contribution?
MANUSCRIPT STRUCTURE DIAGNOSIS
A focused review of how your research question, methods, results and conclusions fit together. Receive specific revision priorities before you submit.
01 / KoiPaper
Four connected parts of your argument, with attention to missing explanations and unsupported claims.
Is the question explicit? Does the introduction explain the gap and the contribution?
Are the design, data, participants or materials described clearly enough to understand the study?
Do the results answer the stated question? Are figures and tables connected to the text?
Are claims supported by the results, with appropriate limitations and boundaries?
| Priority | Manuscript location | Issue and revision action |
|---|---|---|
| High | Introduction · final paragraph | The research question is not explicit. State it directly and connect it to the identified research gap. |
| Medium | Methods · sampling | The sampling period is missing. Add the dates and clarify the selection criteria. |
| Check | Discussion · limitations | Check whether the design limitations explain how broadly the results can be interpreted. |
Examples show the intended format. Actual comments depend on your manuscript; no acceptance prediction or quality score is promised.
Complete payment using your verified account.
Include the paid order number so the manuscript can be linked to your purchase.
Review the priorities and apply the suggested changes. Delivery is to your registered email.
Journal selection compares your manuscript with journals. Structure diagnosis reviews the organisation and reasoning of the manuscript itself and is delivered as a separate service.
The diagnosis and its filename follow the manuscript language. English, Spanish and Arabic manuscripts are currently supported.
After payment has been confirmed and your manuscript has been received. Keep your order number for any delivery enquiry.